mlb – View From Left Field

The Marlins Rebuild Has Ended

After the trade deadline, the Miami Marlins have a major league roster that is almost identical to the pre-deadline roster. The only major leaguers traded were OF Jesus Sanchez and C Nick Fortes. Reactions from the most sophisticated analysts from Marlins social media accounts were a combination of surprise and mild disappointment that the front office did not do more to exchange relief pitchers, or veteran starters such as Cal Quantrill or even Edward Cabrera and/or Sandy Alcantara, for prospect capital at the deadline.

However, after time had passed, many of us agreed that the overall picture is quite positive and reassuring: the new front office in just a year and a half has built the foundations of a competitive team. The timetable for the Marlins to realistically compete for a playoff spot is 2026, but the front office is rewarding the players and the coaching staff at the major league level in 2025 for the sustained success the club has had over the past two months, when the Fish have been among the best teams in major league baseball.

What often gets overlooked in discussions of rebuilds is the interplay between acquiring enough foundational talent to compete long-term and rewarding the players and coaches on the field when they do start to turn things around. It’s fair to say that the Marlins front office has more “building” to do that will likely involve major trades of veteran talent in the offseason. At the same time, this is no longer a “rebuild” given that the goal will be creating a sustainable playoff caliber team in 2026 and beyond. The vision of the new front office under Peter Bendix was to get to the point where the entire major and minor league system was revamped through a unified player development system of over one hundred new hires that would help the organization identify, acquire and develop young players at all levels of the minors (and majors) via trades, waiver wire pickups, Rule V acquisitions and the annual MLB player draft.

These aspects of the rebuild are fast-advanced, though not complete. Marlins fans that wanted to see a lot of trades at the trade deadline to continue a “rebuild” through consecutive years felt that opportunities may have been lost to add more talent to the system. I certainly felt that more trades were necessary as recently as a few weeks ago, but my attitude shifted as the Marlins kept winning games and series, including nine of the last eleven series played, which included only one tied series and one lost series.

The calculation by the Bendix-led front office was to trade key players only if the returns were high enough to help the Marlins compete in 2026 and beyond. The offers for Edward Cabrera, Sandy Alcantara and even relief pitchers such as Anthony Bender did not meet this criteria. There was another factor that often goes overlooked: the front office hired the new coaching staffs at all levels of the system, including a brand new major league coaching staff entrusted with developing the youngest roster in baseball. When the players and the coaching staff had sustained success on the field, they earned the right to continue the momentum established.

The front office, including Bendix, has used the word “culture” more than any other word when talking about sustained success. Part of what that means is rewarding the players and coaches who have successfully adopted the new player development system and “culture” to win games for a sustained period of time. Rather than block that process, the front office wants to encourage this development success and to cultivate its further growth.

To me, this is a ratification of my high expectations of this new front office. They have put themselves in a position to build strategically for both the short- and long-term. That means the Marlins are no longer the type of team that sells valuable assets to the big revenue clubs at firesale prices. When you trade with the Marlins now, you have a front office with the evaluation tools to acquire fair value back to the team, and a development system far advanced from its predecessors. For avid and casual fans, the ballpark experience is already enriched. The upcoming Yankee series will be far more entertaining with the Marlins able to field a team that has surged over the past two months, rather than having to watch a shell of a previously good product stumble to the finish line for yet another season. The hope is not 3, 4 or 5 years away—it’s there in front of our eyes right now, waiting to be built up, not torn down.

The Miami Marlins and Baseball at the 2025 All Star Break

A lot has happened since my last post. Namely the Miami Marlins have been one of the hottest teams in baseball. The team set a club record with 11 straight road wins. The lineup has been bolstered ever since the switch of Otto Lopez from 2b to ss and Xavier Edwards from ss to 2b. The new front office has proven its ongoing ability to add lots of value from players released by other clubs. What many casual observers do not see are the ways that the entire infrastructure of the team is being rebuilt at every level of the system. The comments of big leaguers and top minor league prospects repeat a steady refrain: players are getting steady and sophisticated feedback that has helped them incorporate new tools to aid their own development as pitchers and hitters.

This does not mean that the team is ready to contend right now. What we are seeing is the adding of layers of good quality depth at every level of the minor league system. The major league team has a few quality starters that figure to play a long-term role in producing a winning roster for years to come. However, for that to happen, potential star players need to be added to the mix. This current system, from the majors to the minors, is producing good talent widely distributed. But the few potential stars or superstars has kept the rankings (and future ceiling) of big league competitiveness lower than it will take to challenge the top clubs in the NL East, namely the Phillies and Mets. The Braves are having a rare poor season, but I would expect them to pivot relatively quickly to a playoff caliber team again in seasons ahead. The Nationals are in a bit of chaos now, lagging behind the Marlins, especially in pitching development.

The building blocs for future Marlins playoff teams are readily identifiable: Eury Perez and Agustin Ramirez are foundational type players. These two potential stars or superstars will soon be complemented by catcher Joe Mack, who is back to dominating at AAA. Meanwhile, the good players poised to continue to produce value for the big league club: Kyle Stowers, Griffin Conine, Otto Lopez and Xavier Edwards. I love the rapid development of OF Jakob Marsee, one of the players acquired in the Luis Arraez trade, whose skills are elevating across the board at AAA Jacksonville with ongoing high on-base percentage bolstered by improved contact rates, more power, great baserunning and basestealing, and good defense at the corners. His emergence makes the trade of Jesus Sanchez even more likely–see the excellent work by the Fish on First team on this. Dane Myers remains valuable to the Fish–probably more valuable with the team rather than as a trade chip, with his ability to play CF and produce solid offensive numbers.

The pitching staff of 2026 could be poised to elevate the club to greater heights: Eury Perez, the return of Ryan Weathers, the emergence of Janson Junk (signed to a minor league deal but now posting outstanding major league numbers), the eventual callup of Robby Snelling and the potential star-in-watiting Thomas White, alongside the return of Braxton Garrett, added depth with Adam Mazur, the return of Max Myer (though likely to be a bullpen arm going forward) and an entire corps of elite relievers being developed at high levels of the minors, to complement the excellent work of standout waiver acquisition Ronny Henriquez in the majors, gives the team plenty of room for maneuver at the trade deadline this year and going foward in the offseason and for 2026.

On less encouraging news, the fact that Sandy Alcantara has performed so poorly and that the best starting pitcher of 2025, Edward Cabrera, had to exit his last start with elbow fatigue, is very bad timing for getting good trade returns for these two….it will be interesting to see what the front office does at the dealine, given these circumstances.

Despite encouraging signs for the Fish, the warning cloud that hangs over MLB is the end of the current collective bargaining agreement at the conclusion of the 2026 season. MLB Commissioner Rob Manfred is already doing battle with the Players Association in an attempt to divide the players from each other with the goal of pushing through a salary cap after 2026. That MLB owners never learn lessons from their past failures seems to be a given here. Manfred wants to convince the players that not having a salary cap has made them worse off in revenue distribution when compared to the revenues distributed to players in leagues that have salary caps. This is a false argument that conceals the extent to which the owners have taken advantage of the most restrictive reserve system in all of professional sports to drive down revenues distributed to the best young superstars. It is the 6-year waiting period for free agency and the caps on earnings through year 3 that has lowered the MLB players overall revenues in recent years, enabled by an ownership strategy of squeezing mid-level MLB free agents and relying on young, cheap, controllable players instead. I’ve written about this extensively for Just Baseball during the last owner lock out. I’m afraid my analysis will not be out of date at the end of the 2026 season, when another owner lockout looms:

https://www.justbaseball.com/author/ron-cox/

Who Will Bendix Trade?

Who is Peter Bendix most likely to trade before the trading deadline this year? What do I mean by a 2-3 year rebuild? And finally what outcome would indicate some level of success or failure? I’ll tackle each of these three angles below.

First, the players most likely to be dealt, based on whom is most likely to get a quality return, and I’m okay with all of these:

Anthony Bender

Ronny Henriquez

Jesus Sanchez

Edward Cabrera

Dane Myers

Liam Hicks

I am not opposed to listening on ANYONE, though as many have said: the untouchables would have to be Agustin Ramirez and Eury Perez. The key for me is to avoid a perpetual rebuild of a rebuild, the kind of churn where you fail to see much progress in wins and losses over the next two or three years. Even Bendix and Sherman made it clear, by their own admission, that another 100 loss season even this year would be disappointing—that was at this year’s fanfest, and was said outright by the owner and Bendix to kick things off.

If there is too much churn beyond the players I’m listing here, then the team is spinning its wheels. This list will already ensure another 100 loss season and that is okay as long as the return both deepens the depth in the farm system, adds a player or two that could be a star, and provides a mix of highly ranked lower level minor leaguers with major league ready pieces that complement what the Marlins have.

My definition of a short rebuild of 2 to 3 years is improvement in record and an identifiable core that we can envision as ready to be playoff competitive. I’m not being rigid or unrealistic here, just suggesting that in 2-3 years, let’s get past losing 100 games every season, or even 90-100 games.

And finally the owner needs to start spending more money in 2026. That means elevating payroll closer to what the Athletics did this year by bringing in free agents that were pricey but filled key needs. The Fish will have to do that for the starting rotation and will need to add a quality bat or two to make 2026 more interesting and productive for the club and the fan base.

State of the Marlins Update

A lot has happened since my last Miami Marlins post, so I wanted to provide some brief thoughts on aspects of the Marlins 2025 season, especially after the low point of losing to the historically awful Rockies twice, and before my wife and I take a road trip to see a Marlins game in Tampa on Saturday against the Rays.

My overall optimism about the new front office has not changed. I predicted 64 wins this year, and that looks about accurate, specially since there will be trades at the deadline. The Marlins should trade any and every bullpen arm that can command sufficient value—bullpen arms are the most volatile aspects of any team sport and therefore should face no restrictions in trade discussions—anyone should be available at the right price. I think that’s also true for Jesus Sanchez, whose value is as high as it’s ever going to be. These make sense as strategic trades.

However, the Marlins need to be very careful about how many of the remaining young core they part with. I’m not opposed to trading Edward Cabrera but the return for a pitcher who is controllable through 2029 would have to be very good, and would need to include major league ready talent. I’m not interested in trading young controllable major league talent for a bunch of great A ball prospects. The team’s timetable should not be 4 or 5 years, but instead 2-3 years.

To make the two to three year timetable workable, the Major League Baseball Players Association needs to keep the heat turned up on Marlins owner Bruce Sherman, who needs to spend a lot more starting in 2026. I understand not spending in 2025, because we needed to see which of these young players are part of the core over the next 2-3 years. To me, Stowers, Conine, Myers, Ramirez, Eury Perez qualify. Some are concerned with Stowers’ strikeout percentage, which is legitimate, and he will be prone to slumps, but he’s also shown an ability to make adjustments quickly and he will get better. He’s had a great year and should be a consistent 3 WAR player at least. I also like Otto Lopez at short, as early defensive metrics are good and if he can just hit close to league average, he’s good for 2 WAR a year. At the very least he’s young enough to be a capable asset for the team in a 2-3 year window, especially with the lack of SS options on the market. Xavier Edwards has been disappointing but I do like his overall value at 2B much better than at SS, and I think he will have strong second half. I wish the team would play Hicks more, but I can certainly understand trading him if the return is good, as the club has Joe Mack as the catcher of the future, and Ramirez has shown the ability to catch occasionally and be a productive DH otherwise.

The pitching staff of the next two years should include Weathers and Perez, but the rest is cloudy. Max Meyer has struggled mightily with his fastball, and that caught up to him dramatically in his last few starts. Given the thinness of Marlins pitching, even with promising Robby Snelling on the way, a struggling Alcantara is probably worth keeping rather than selling low, and Edward Cabrera may not be as easy to replace in the next two to three years as people assume. You can never have enough pitching, and most young pitchers fail. Thomas White is expected to be a front line starter but who knows and who knows when. So the team should be very cautious here when making more deals.

My criticisms:

The lineup choices and the handling of starting pitchers at times has been baffling. And the failure to trust Dane Myers against righties, even after proving himself as one of the best hitters, is frustrating. I like the bullpen management though.

Bendix needs to be more honest and upfront about direction of the team for fans. His interviews have to be among the worst I’ve seen from GMs, who are typically bad. He could learn something from how Dombrowski has always operated, even without resources.

Those are my thoughts for now, I’m always going to be a fan of this team in part because of the history of dysfunction which gives the Marlins an underdog status that will make it that much sweeter if this version of the team turns into a success story. There has been progress, but there needs to be more, and relatively soon….I’m a baseball fan, and the Marlins will always be on my radar but so will my other favorite teams like the Cardinals and Rays. I’ll end up focusing on the teams that are winning down the stretch if they are in the race….someday the Marlins need to join that group.

State of the Marlins Under Bendix

The clock starts this year on assessment of the new Miami Marlins front office, hired just a year and a half ago by Marlins owner Bruce Sherman. So far there are plenty of reasons to justify long-term optimism. The record this year is far less important than seeing if this first group of young players have a chance to stick with the team as it builds a solid core. The performance of position players are very encouraging.

Before he went down with a gruesome season-ending shoulder injury, Griffin Conine had picked up where he left off last year, providing perhaps the most balanced position player performance among Marlins starters: solid OBP, SLG, fielding, and baserunning. He will be ready in 2026 and should be an important part of the future. He’s proven he can hit lefties, which makes him an everyday player. The other standout is Kyle Stowers, who is mashing the ball consistently, is better at laying off the high fastball, and is drawing walks to supplement the extra base hits. He too looks to be a keeper and a solid every day starter. In addition, when Derek Hill was healthy, the outfield defense ranked near the top in all of baseball. Dane Myers is a solid contributor who has shown plus offensive skills and can play all three outfield positions.

On the infield, the situation is much more mixed. Connor Norby looks to be part of the core but still has work to do both at 3b and generating more consistent extra base production at the plate. However, at this point he’s an average MLB starter. Xavier Edwards has taken a step back and in my view is not a long-term SS. If he regains his hitting stroke, he could be viable at 2B. But it’s too early to give up on Otto Lopez, whose defense at 2B gives him value. 1B Matt Mervis is intriguing because of the power. The team needs to give him time to see if he can make adjustments to lower his high strikeout rate. It’s tended to be feast or famine for him.

Agustin Ramirez looks to be the real deal: the most exciting hitting prospect that the Marlins have on their roster in the Bruce Sherman era, and that includes Jazz, whom he was acquired for. Ramirez approach is exceptional in providing the full package of skills: good contact, on base and power—he hits the ball hard consistently. He most likely profiles as a DH/1B/part time catcher. AAA catcher Joe Mack appears to be the starting catcher of the future, as he excels in every facet of his game. Eric Wagaman was a good find, and has been a solid contributor as a 1b/3B and corner OF option, though he does have defensive limitations.

The starting pitching has been an unexpected disaster, with Sandy struggling mightily. However, reinforcements are going to help remake this rotation. Max Meyer has been stellar, mostly, and appears ready to be a top-of-the-rotation starter going forward. He will soon be complemented by Ryan Weathers and Eury Perez, both coming off injuries, and eventually Adam Mazur and high rising prospect Robby Snelling will be given their chances.

The bullpen has several high leverage relievers that have done well, paired with a group of poor performers who have tended to be used in games the Fish are losing. I have been very impressed with the way the manager and coaching staff have deployed the bullpen arms. This is a smart and very advanced group from both a coaching and analytic perspective.

Contrast how well the rebuild is going versus what is happening with the traded Marlins. With the exception of Jesus Luzardo and Tanner Scott, the rest of the former Fish have not been productive: Jake Burger is in the minors, Jazz is hurt again and is hitting below .200, Bryan de la Cruz is in the minors, Luis Arraez may have a good batting average but his overall production has not been very good, Josh Bell is hitting over 50% below league average. Yeah, the previous group was nothing to ever keep.

Overall the record for the first full year of the rebuild has been close to expectations, but the progress is evident when looking at how extensively the entire major and minor league system has been transformed. The front office should have a much better idea of what needs to be added in 2026 to make the team better and more competitive. That means Sherman needs to start spending money. It was fine to have a transition year to assess young talent, but the goal after this year should be measurable improvement of the on-field product.

I do expect things to start to take an upswing in 2026 and hopefully go higher in 2027, if the owners don’t lock out the players that year, which would be the season after the collective bargaining agreement ends after the conclusion of the 2026 season.